“7vos 10, 1961
THE SENT
OJH. SIL A Reorganization
/agbryit; 0 worked in EJ
feullsveiing vierwis 93 Gods vybyr during the
10 F nod wovred ts a parleie CLA consultant in the years since.
tia eakanco, CIA’s recurd no prokaily been very gent in the
nature o’ cimndisine spem”
“KI
SECRET SuE SANEI2ED
1
06RSISN.
la
%
U-M-1N9
T
ARRB/C.C. 9/02
5
June 30, 1961
u a m ^ ^ -----
DETERIORATION
MEMORANDUM FC THE PRESIDENT
2 -7
SUBJECT: CIA Reorganization
- - - - - __ ^ v ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ B a j THE
9
I submit the following views as one ■ho worked I”
“Committee,
"The Central Intelligence Agency shouldEoVa nothing to do with policy."
Yet, in the yesra since, CIA has, in effect, ‘made’ policy in many
parte ef the world. A number of governments 111! in power know
that they have even been targets of CIA attempts 0% overthrow •”
“memorandum to the Senate Armed Services Committee,
“The Central Intelligence Agency should have nothing to do with policy. "
AR
THE ORIGINAL
Yet, in the years since, CIA has, in effect, ‘made’ policy in many
IBR
parts the world. A number of governments still la power know”
“by the U. S. Government if they were
presumed to be legitimately the statement of another government.
CIA Personnel Under State Cover
The DD/P is making a thorough review of State cover directed
toward insuring that CIA personnel are not out of line in their various
allowa”
“need for revamping of the "intelli
gence set-up" of the United States. In a footnote in that
memorandum, Schlesinger notes that the CIA is not able to
control its operatives once they are in the field and of
the attendant dangers this poses. (See page 6 of the memo.)
HW 509”
“Committee,
"The Central Intelligence Agency should have nothing to do with policy."
Yot. to the yeare since, CIA has, to effect, ‘made’ policy in many
parts of the world. A number of governments still in power know
that they have even bean targets of CIA attempts at overthrow”
“~.3W
CEARET
OLORLI
" '(Z) Mail Coverage. 'Another much needed intelli-ns
gence tool is mail coverage.. • Its importance has been
proven in the past. I have the impression that it has
been discontinued, and I would suggest that our represen-
tatives should confer and exami”
“14-00000
July 3 NotDraftSent
MEMORANDUM FOR: DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE
SUBJECT: NCFE-CIA RELATIONS
1. When this Division was delegated the responsibility of
conducting CIA relations with NCFE it was immediately apparent that
a variety of problems existed whi”
“Committee,
"The Central Intelligence Agency should have zething to do with policy."
Yet, in the years since, CIA has, in effect, ‘made’ policy in many
parte 0 the world. A number of governments still in power know
that they have even been targets of CIA attempts 2% overthrow ”
“SANT16P vL If 16\ d. 5/11
6
SECRET CIA
June 30, 1961
MEMORANDUM FOR THE PRESIDENT
SUBJECT: CIA Reorganization
1 submit the following views as one who worked in OSS during the
war and served as a periodic CIA consultant in the years since.
On balance, CIA’s record has p”
“counter-intelligence effort will bring research and analytical
19
work to bear which would give an analysis and an assessment
20
E the situation, which should be f value to policy-makers
21
in the government, to the intelligence directorate of the CI.,
22
to the Director ”
“6
SECRET
7.
I has meant too that the State Department, often apprised of an
operation only in its later stages, is under great pressure to
endorse the operation as already mounted because cf the alleged
evil consequences of exercising a veto. I well remember Tom
Mann’s re”
“CIA •* photographic interpre-
tation, biographical data, foreign breadcast monitoring, overt collec-
tion, mape, etc. There might be in addition a Joint Intelligence Board
with representatives from all the intelligence agencies and with e
State Department or White House chairman.”
“CREr
Z.
conception of the relationship between operations and intelligence.
The memorandum also suggs sta ways in which some cf those prob-
lemns can perhaps be alleviated
1. CIA Autonomy •
CIA conducts three main forms cf secret work; clandestine intelli-
gence collect”
“in your para. a.)
4. The remedy which is being developed as a consequence of this
investigation is the re-definition of the responsibilities of CEA and
authorities of NCFE and the development of new procedures for the conduct
of relations between NCFE and CIA. These definitio”
“SECRET
analysis, for FBI personnel. • In soliciting your views on
the desirability of this type of training, I wish to reiterate
our willingness to provide such instruction. It would be
designed to expose the needs of the Intelligence Community
in depth, thus making the Cur”
“confirmation hearings to ensure that the Agency will remain •
within its legislative charter. ' I am arranging for the published *
transcripts of those hearings to be circulated throughout the
Agency for compliance, and at that time will reaffirm the specific.
direction made ”
“. Washington, O.C. 20003
19
i have not cooperated to the extent that the military commanders
20
1: in the field have wanted.
Some of this has to do with priorities that are imposed
21
22 on the CIA representatives from Washington. Some of it has
‘ S hw iis sa g Otr
”
“CONFIDENTIAL
4. In addition to the "category II" items, there are
a number of additional subjects largely geographic in nature
for which the DCI feels CIA should assume responsibility
for preparing comprehensive papers. In view of the
apparent adversary relationship between ”
“*‘% wor he ‘a
pKFA
4.4
Now the next gogbien refers to the fentral Intelligence
Agency in general. Now lesganino so much of our inquiry is
Focused on the Central Intelligence Agency, we have a rather
■1 long series of recommendations regarding it.
R Now the sections ar”
“congressional committee; it did not involve revisions that, would
significantly modify the structure or the powers of the CIA it-
self. The Committee has not been authorized to hire additional
staff personnel for the purpose of this legislation. Further
more, we were under i”
“SECRET
6.
2. Covert politic) operate ns tochnieally reqaire Etnte
Department cloerenne. In practice, however, CIA bns often boon
able t ceiza the initiative in ways which reduce State’s role almost
to that of a rubber stamp.
This hus been partly the 0000:9wauca c the supe”
“would create
some risk of creating suspicions that they were or are
associated with this Agency or the U.S. Government. If CIA
were unable to locate a particular source, there would still
be some risk in releasing his name. Just because CIA cannot
locate him, does not mean t”
“SECRET
U 205 meant too that the State Department, eites apprised ef an
operation only in Ita later s%0gen, 10 under grant proncure to
endorse the operation 34 already mountad because cl the alleged
evil consequences of onorcistug & vetc. I well remember Tom
Monn’s ses06rk t”
“NA-HSM* F14 :83
‘rember 27 because it has -bracketed portion that we might
considerably do away with.
That's page 40.
v। The bracketed portion navs that the NSC would approve
/7.
all counter-intelligence activities of the CIA in the United
*3
States and- it spells ou”
“SECREI
9.
the uighot of €9 Conerols’ revnst ia Algerl?. pe$*ezo-by noted
with amnueemznt that the top floor van ablase with lights. (I am
informed that Ambassador Cavin was able to ascora entrance that
night to the CIA offices cely with difficulty.) .
CLA 10 moparently d”
“SECRET
6.
la
2. Covert political operations technically require State
Department clearance In practice, however, CIA has often been
able to seize the initiative in ways which reduce State's role almost
to that of a rubber mtalep.
This has been partly the consequence of th”
“risk of creating suspicions that they were or are
associated with this Agency or the U.S. Government. If CIA
were unable to locate a particular source, there would still
be some risk in releasing his name. Just because CIA cannot
locate him, does not mean that he is not alive”
“Sttmtl
8.
0A
% wdlothan220,0 freprempu / under military or other 'mitato
3Eficial cover)." Originally the uge of Siste Department cover for
0° Moe personnel was supposed to be strictly limited and temporary.
be bullen-Correx-Jackeon report stated in 1948, "The CTA should
”
“approximately 100 briefings. Most of these briefings dealt with the
organization and activities of the Central Intelligence Agency, but also
included a full day spent with the Department of State in addition to several
briefings on State Department activities and its relations”
“INTERVIEW AND MEETING SUMMARY Page 19 f___ 21
jaw
an alien, a form was submitted by FBI. "Cixthe n
got FBI data on the alien and FBI had notice so
it could protect any operation.
Regarding possible spies in foreign intelligence
agencies, if the FBI discovers any it evaluate”
“In such cases
it will be apprecia
ted if you will advise us
of suc
h r
eferral in order that we m
ay
anticipate
the possible further interest of the Commission
(?)
and initiate certain preparatory to meeting its
needs. (CSCI -3/559/710)
CIA
The policy
of
eliminating
reference to
”
“SECRET SENSITIVE
8. That CIA counterintelligence liaison
abroad be improved through a judicious aug-
mentation of exchange of counterintelligence
information, including penetration leads, by
augmentation of U.S. capacity for leadership
in dealing with the common advers”
“14-00000
- 2 -
(3) NCFE has not only failed to provide information
about its activities, but had generally expanded
its relations with government agencies in an
effort to play one agency against another and,
indeed, in many cases play the personnel of one
■ agency agains”
“ould so advise the Seat of Government, clearly
setting forth your reasons. In this connection; there
may be instances
where continuin
g CIA p
ursuit of positive intelligence would conflict with
the Bureau s discharge of its in
te”
“FOR THE AGENCY IS WHERE THERE IS "...CLEAR AND CONVINCING EVIDENCE
THAT THE THREAT TO THE CONDUCT OF US INTELLIGENCE ACTIVITIES AND
FOREIGN RELATIONS OUTWEIGHS THE PUBLIC INTEREST AND THAT
DISCLOSURE WOULD REVEAL AN INTELLIGENCE METHOD CURRENTLY UTILIZED
AND NOT OFFICIALLY DI”
WITHHELD·p. 1·source: semanticDerived signal68%NOTES from CIA
“SECRE[
J.
For ikn part, CIA Lias developed A whale series 01 functions poral-
.lelinng already existing functions of the State Department, and cf
the Defense Department as well. Today it bas its own political
desks and military staffs; it has in effect its own foreign servi”
“DLL 2l
7. .w •
la
It has meant too the the State Department, often apprised of an
operation only in its ater stages, is under great pressure to
endorse the operatic as already mounted because the alleged
evil consequences as exercising a veto. I well remember Tom
Mann's ”
“13-00000
13. The meeting was throughout a cordial one and 1 detected
no evidence of a critical attitude towards the Agency’s covert
action program. -
-7 ill
CORD MEYER, JR.
Chief
Covert Action Staff
Distribution:
Orig. - Director, CIA
1 - Exec. Director
1 - DDP
I ”
“0P. 44. at 043
1 intelligence information. that this would not, you know, that
2 at the same time the Agency could be directed to perform such
3 other collection tasks as directed by the NSC.
4 In other words, the point is that certainly they do
5 some overt collection. For”
“SECTET
5.
14, peralloom and Policy
wertd-on < iilium,■ to we vuewe teewww semew vowon tone, who Minim
Clandestine activities abould 20 acneaned net only in the context
of their relationship to an open society but *le® in tito catsext of their
ralzticnebip to United States”
“SECRET
6
15.
The structure which would meet the criteria suggested in this
memorandum would be as follows: ‘
1) The State Department would be granted general
clearance authority over all clandestine activity. This
might be effectuated on the British model by the appointment”
“SECRET IC
15.
The structure which would meet the criteria suggested in this
■.I
memorandum would e as follows:
1) The State Department would be granted general
.clearance authiruty over all clandestine activity. This.
• right be effectuated on the British model by the ap”
“IC.
.to”
8.
(the other 2200 BTC presumably under military OF er —State
official cover). Oridnally the us of State Departs r for
CIA personnel W38 supposed 3 trictly limited as
The Dulles-Correa- ackson report stated 1948, e CIA should
not use State Departtuent cover is a ”
“operations.
The Committee intends to approach the issues of the CIA’s
domestic activities with a broad perspective, realizing,
as I am sure you agree, that the' threats to United States
security and the need to protect sources and methods of
intelligence, as well as CIA inst”
“government.
There have beon troubles of a comparable revtin
B
00t onalsverst
00
in a
2566
0
CIA has I gold‘ that, in 3ush CE88S, neither the Embassy nsr the Depart
0
is noszeelly
:
mint in Washington informed this type 1 operation.
n
F A i-
-
ndexciseassho”
“instance) widely blamed for
,developments which it 1s wholly innocent.
"
The argument of this memorandum is that CIA’s trouble can be traced
to the autonomy with which the agency ha .............
n permitted to operate
1-5
: and that this autonomy is dno to three main ca”
“-2 -
1) Clarify CIA’s mission and charter by
amending the National Security Act of 1947 to'
reflect:
--that included in the proper functions
6f the Agency are (a) collection of foreign
intelligence information; (b) conduct of
activities to carry out CIA's counter-
”
“SECRET
6.
2. Covert
Department clearance. operations
political In practice,technically hasState
require
however, CXA often been
able to seize the initiative to ways which reduce State’s role almost
to that of a rubber stamp.
This has been partly the consequence of the s”